Portland’s Board of Schooling upsets mother and father with college selection vote

Annoyed Portland, Maine mother and father lashed out towards the Portland Board of Schooling for…

Portland’s Board of Schooling upsets mother and father with college selection vote

Annoyed Portland, Maine mother and father lashed out towards the Portland Board of Schooling for limiting college students’ potential to decide on their most well-liked highschool throughout a voting session Tuesday night time.

At a board assembly on Tuesday, mother and father had been upset to search out out that the varsity board voted to vary the district’s highschool admissions coverage, which entails college students being randomly compelled to attend a college.

Forty-three years of college selection in Portland was modified on Tuesday night time when board members mentioned a proposal to vary the highschool choice course of because of concern over a “disproportionality of enrollment” and a want to “restrict the distinction at school variety composition.”

Portland public college college students have been in a position to choose the highschool they wish to attend because the late Seventies. Whereas one college referred to as Casco Bay Excessive Faculty is just not assured admission, all different college students had been assured entrance at their chosen college Deering or Portland Excessive Faculty. Enrollments within the two excessive faculties have “fluctuated” over time. 


Rep. Luke Messer, R-Ind., speaks throughout a rally to advertise the significance of college selection as a part of “Nationwide Faculty Selection Week,” in Russell Constructing on January 18, 2018. (Photograph By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Name)
((Photograph By Tom Williams/CQ Roll Name))

Portland Public Colleges Superintendent Xavier Botana stated that the fluctuation is just not “endemic” to both college. Nevertheless, it’s “endemic” that the varsity district has “a lot of these variations.”

“So, the difficulty related to that’s–what brings us right here … the disproportionality of enrollment causes us to have some pressures on the programming that’s out there at each faculties,” Botana stated.

“The demographics of the faculties have differed considerably over time and I believe that that’s what prompted a re-evaluation of this after we introduced enrollment figures again to the board … the board was shocked to see how disparate the enrollment was,” he added.

Board members stated they wish to see no higher than a 30-person distinction at school dimension between Portland and Deering. They noticed that over the previous 5 years, college students’ most well-liked Deering over Portland.  


After the adjustments, which is able to start with this 12 months’s eighth graders, college students will nonetheless be capable of select between Portland and Deering excessive faculties. Nevertheless, the district will randomly choose and type ninth graders into one college to “restrict the distinction in enrollment, restrict the distinction at school variety composition, and cap the share of scholars who don’t obtain their first selection.”

Solely college students with out “variety components” can be included within the pool of scholars who may very well be moved. College students with variety components embrace these experiencing homelessness, college students with individualized training plans, college students eligible without spending a dime and decreased lunch, and English language or multilingual learners.

The board handed the decision on a 5-2 vote. What drew ire from mother and father was the board’s classification of “variety components” and the way the board reportedly disregarded parental enter. 

A mother of children in the Los Angeles Unified School District joins members of Los Angeles Leftists for Choice and Unity as they held a rally against the LAUSD student COVID-19 vaccination mandate outside the Stanley Mosk Courthouse.

A mom of youngsters within the Los Angeles Unified Faculty District joins members of Los Angeles Leftists for Selection and Unity as they held a rally towards the LAUSD scholar COVID-19 vaccination mandate outdoors the Stanley Mosk Courthouse.
(Al Seib / Los Angeles Instances through Getty Photos)


A guardian of two college students in seventh and fifth grade named Ryan Hutchins, who teaches at Deering Excessive Faculty, stated throughout public remark classes that he helps the modification as a result of there’s a “notion drawback that one college is healthier than the opposite.” The Deering Excessive Faculty alum stated that the division has “damage” town of Portland.

“I believe limiting selection, or I’ve heard the phrase guardrails on selection being placed on … that could be a Band-aid. It’s a Band-Support that might be wanted. However I believe it’s one that might trigger extra animosity than it might assist,” Hutchins stated.

Hutchins’ take was in stark distinction to the heated response from many different mother and father.

“As I spoke earlier than, it actually would not make sense to me that in case you’re homeless, you are free and decreased lunch, have an IEP otherwise you’re an English-language learner that you just get your first selection,” Ann Marie Gribbin-Bouchard stated throughout the public remark interval earlier than the vote on the decision.

“Let’s all keep in mind the definition of discrimination: the unjust or prejudicial therapy of various classes of individuals or issues particularly on the grounds of race, age, or intercourse; this can be discrimination towards the inhabitants that does not match this standards.”

Far more of the frustration was displayed on the Portland’s Board of Schooling’s remark part below the reside stream of the assembly.

“Not one individual within the public thinks it is a good concept. Nothing just like the cut up SRO opinion,” Carly Peters wrote.

“It’s so disappointing that the Board doesn’t take public choice into consideration,” one other commenter, Stephanie Inexperienced Albert, stated.

“That is discrimination towards the inhabitants which are within the lottery that’s being proposed!” Brian Bouchard stated.

Fox Information Digital reached out to Portland Public Colleges for a remark however didn’t hear again.

Widespread calls for varsity selection and parental rights have emerged after states carried out lockdown measures throughout the coronavirus pandemic.


Faculty selection, or offering all households with alternate options to the general public faculties they’re zoned for, might be expanded by way of a number of avenues on the state stage, together with college voucher packages, tax-credit scholarship packages, particular person tuition tax credit score packages and deductions, and training financial savings accounts (ESAs). Constitution faculties, magnet faculties, and homeschooling are additionally types of college selection packages.

Republican governors made important inroads in pushing college selection laws in recent times with many payments together with ESAs. For example, Tennessee Gov. Invoice Lee pushed ESAs after being thwarted for nearly three years. ESAs in Tennessee would offer eligible households as much as roughly $7,000 in public tax {dollars} on personal education tuition and different pre-approved bills. 

Moreover, Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey signed probably the most “monumental” ESA program within the nation, permitting financial savings accounts to have common eligibility for all 1.1 million Ok-12 college students within the state.

Leave a Reply